Advertisement
Special Issue Article
Government and Medicine

The Quality of Medical Care: Methods for assessing and monitoring the quality of care for research and for quality assurance programs.

Science26 May 1978Vol 200, Issue 4344pp. 856-864DOI: 10.1126/science.417400

Abstract

This article classifies the major approaches to the assessment of the process and outcomes of medical care. The apparent need to safeguard and enhance the quality of care has led to the institution of mechanisms that subject care to constant review so that deficiencies may be found and corrected. The article reviews the developments that led to the involvement of the federal government in this activity through its sponsorship of professional standards review organizations (PSRO's). The major features of the PSRO's are described and their possible effects discussed. It is too early to say how the PSRO's will fare, but should they fail to accomplish their objectives the pressure for more radical solutions will be difficult to resist.

Get full access to this article

View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.

Already a subscriber or AAAS Member?

References

Assessing Physician Performance in Ambulatory Care: 57 (1976).
Assessing Quality in Health Care: An Evaluation: 79 (1976).
HLTH SERV REP 11: 332 (1976).
New York Academy of Medicine, Maternal Mortality in New York City: A Study of All Puerperal Deaths, 1930-1932 (1933).
New York Academy of Medicine, Perinatal Mortality in New York City: Responsible Factors (1955).
Professional Standards Review, Pub. Law 92-603: 101 (1970).
SURGERY US: 2132 (1976).
ANDERSON, H, STATISTICAL SURVEILLANCE OF A TITLE XIX PROGRAM, AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH AND THE NATIONS HEALTH 59: 275 (1969).
AVERILL, R.F., COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS OF CONTINUED STAY CERTIFICATION, MEDICAL CARE 15: 158 (1977).
BARNETT, G.O., ASSESSING PHYSICIAN: 140 (1976).
BELLIN, L.E., PSRO-QUALITY CONTROL - OR GIMMICKRY, MEDICAL CARE 12: 1012 (1974).
BERG, R.L., HLTH STATUS INDEXES (1973).
BRESLOW, L, QUANTITATIVE APPROACH TO WORLD-HEALTH-ORGANIZATION DEFINITION OF HEALTH - PHYSICAL, MENTAL AND SOCIAL WELL-BEING, INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY 1: 347 (1972).
BROOK, R.H., MEDICAL CARE 14 12 (1976).
BROOK, R.H., MEDICAL CARE 15 9 (1977).
BROOK, R.H., EFFECTIVENESS OF PATIENT CARE IN AN EMERGENCY ROOM, NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE 283: 904 (1970).
BROOK, R.H., QUALITY ASSURANCE CO (1977).
Bunker, J. P., Costs, Risks, and Benefits of Surgery (1977).
Caplow, T., Proceedings: Conference on Professional Self-Regulation-Working Papers on PSRO's June 1975: 8 (n.d.).
CIOCCO, A, PUBLIC HLTH 65: 27 (1950).
CLUTE, K.F., GENERAL PRACTITIONER (1963).
COCHRANE, A.L., EFFECTIVENESS EFFICI (1972).
CURRAN, W.J., AM J PUBLIC HLTH 61: 1977 (1971).
DONABEDIAN, A, GUIDE MEDICAL CARE A 2 (1969).
DONABEDIAN, A, EVALUATING QUALITY OF MEDICAL CARE, MILBANK MEMORIAL FUND QUARTERLY-HEALTH AND SOCIETY 44: 166 (1966).
EISLEE, C.W., ANN INTERN MED 44: 144 (1956).
ELINSON, J, INT J HLTH SERV 6: 377 (1976).
FANSHEL, S, HEALTH-STATUS INDEX AND ITS APPLICATION TO HEALTH-SERVICES OUTCOMES, OPERATIONS RESEARCH 18: 1021 (1970).
Freidson, E., Proceedings: Conference on Professional Self-Regulation-Working Papers on PSRO's, June 1975: 33 (n.d.).
GINSBERG, A.S., DECISION ANALYSIS CL (1971).
GONNELLA, J.S., QUALITY OF PATIENT-CARE - MEASUREMENT OF CHANGE - STAGING CONCEPT, MEDICAL CARE 13: 467 (1975).
GONNELLA, J.S., STAGING CONCEPT - APPROACH TO ASSESSMENT OF OUTCOME OF AMBULATORY CARE, MEDICAL CARE 14: 13 (1976).
GORAN, M.G., MEDICAL CARE 13 4 (1975).
Gosfield, A., Proceedings: Conference on Professional Self-Regulation-Working Papers in PSRO's, June 1975: 50 (n.d.).
GREENFIELD, S, PEER REVIEW BY CRITERIA MAPPING - CRITERIA FOR DIABETES-MELLITUS - USE OF DECISION-MAKING IN CHART AUDIT, ANNALS OF INTERNAL MEDICINE 83: 761 (1975).
HAVIGHURST, C.C., COPING WITH QUALITY-COST TRADE-OFFS IN MEDICAL-CARE - ROLE OF PSROS, NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW 70: 6 (1975).
HAVIGHURST, C.G., UTAH LAW REV 175: 381 (1975).
HUNTLEY, R.R., QUALITY OF MEDICAL CARE - TECHNIQUES AND INVESTIGATION IN OUTPATIENT CLINIC, JOURNAL OF CHRONIC DISEASES 14: 630 (1961).
JACOBS, C.M., MEASURING QUALITY PA: 51 (1976).
Janzen, E., Quality nursing care assurance: Initial survey, paper read at the annual meeting of the American Public Health Association, New Orleans, 23 October (1974).
JUNGFER, C.C., CLINICAL-PERFORMANCE IN AUSTRALIAN GENERAL-PRACTICE, MEDICAL CARE 2: 71 (1964).
KAVET, J, IMPLICATIONS OF PSRO LEGISLATION FOR TEACHING HOSPITAL SECTOR, JOURNAL OF MEDICAL EDUCATION 49: 321 (1974).
KESSNER, D.M., ASSESSMENT MEDICAL C: 174 (1974).
KESSNER, D.M., ASSESSING HEALTH QUALITY - CASE FOR TRACERS, NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE 288: 189 (1973).
LYONS, T.F., RELATIONSHIP OF PHYSICIANS MEDICAL RECORDING PERFORMANCE TO THEIR MEDICAL CARE PERFORMANCE, MEDICAL CARE 12: 714 (1974).
Maglott, D. B., Proceedings: Conference on Professional Self-Regulation-Working Papers on PSRO's, June 1975: 4 (n.d.).
MCCARTHY, E.G., EFFECTS OF SCREENING BY CONSULTANTS ON RECOMMENDED ELECTIVE SURGICAL PROCEDURES, NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE 291: 1331 (1974).
MCDONALD, C.J., USE OF A COMPUTER TO DETECT AND RESPOND TO CLINICAL EVENTS - ITS EFFECT ON CLINICIAN BEHAVIOR, ANNALS OF INTERNAL MEDICINE 84: 162 (1976).
MCNEIL, B.J., MEASURES OF CLINICAL EFFICACY .3. VALUE OF LUNG-SCAN IN EVALUATION OF YOUNG PATIENTS WITH PLEURITIC CHEST PAIN, JOURNAL OF NUCLEAR MEDICINE 17: 163 (1976).
MCNEIL, B.J., PRIMER ON CERTAIN ELEMENTS OF MEDICAL DECISION-MAKING, NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE 293: 211 (1975).
MCNEIL, B.J., MEASURES OF CLINICAL EFFICACY - VALUE OF CASE FINDING IN HYPERTENSIVE RENOVASCULAR DISEASE, NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE 293: 221 (1975).
MOREHEAD, M.A., MAN MED 1: 113 (1976).
Morehead, M. A., A Study of the Quality of Hospital Care Secured by a Sample of Teamster Family Members in New York CityT (1964).
MOSES, L.E., J AM MED ASSOC 203: 422 (1968).
Payne, B. C., Quality of Medical Care: Evaluation and Improvement (1976).
Payne, B. C., Utilization Review: A Handbook for the Medical Staff (1965).
PETERSON, O.L., J MED EDUC 2 31 (1956).
PLISKIN, N, COSTS RISKS BENEFITS: 5 (1977).
RHEE, S.O., FACTORS DETERMINING QUALITY OF PHYSICIAN PERFORMANCE IN PATIENT-CARE, MEDICAL CARE 14: 733 (1976).
ROSENBERGN, S.N., ECLECTIC APPROACH TO QUALITY-CONTROL IN FEE-FOR-SERVICE HEALTH-CARE - NEW-YORK-CITY MEDICAID EXPERIENCE, AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 66: 21 (1976).
ROSENFELD, L.S., QUALITY OF MEDICAL-CARE IN HOSPITALS, AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH AND THE NATIONS HEALTH 47: 856 (1957).
RUTSTEIN, D.D., MEASURING QUALITY OF MEDICAL-CARE - CLINICAL METHOD, NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE 294: 582 (1976).
SANZARO, P.J., MED CARE 6: 123 (1968).
SCHAFFNER, W, MATERNAL MORTALITY IN MICHIGAN - EPIDEMIOLOGIC ANALYSIS, 1950-1971, AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 67: 821 (1977).
SCHWARTZ, W.B., DECISION ANALYSIS AND CLINICAL JUDGMENT, AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE 55: 459 (1973).
SCOTT, W.R., ORG RES HOSP: 72 (1976).
SHAIN, M, STATE LICENSING REGULATIONS AND HOSPITAL LIABILITY, PUBLIC HEALTH REPORTS 81: 581 (1966).
SLEE, V.N., PSRO AND HOSPITALS QUALITY-CONTROL, ANNALS OF INTERNAL MEDICINE 81: 97 (1974).
SPARLING, J.F., HOSPITALS 36: 56 (1962).
SPARLING, J.F., HOSPITALS 36: 62 (1962).
STARFIELD, B, MEASUREMENT OF OUTCOME - PROPOSED SCHEME, MILBANK MEMORIAL FUND QUARTERLY-HEALTH AND SOCIETY 52: 39 (1974).
TOMPKINS, R.K., ANALYSIS OF COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF PHARYNGITIS MANAGEMENT AND ACUTE RHEUMATIC-FEVER PREVENTION, ANNALS OF INTERNAL MEDICINE 86: 481 (1977).
WELCH, C.E., PSROS - PROS AND CONS, NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE 290: 1319 (1974).
WHITE, K.L., CAVEATS FOR PSROS, WESTERN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE 120: 338 (1974).
WILLETT, D.E., MALPRACTICE CLAIMS - WILL THEY INCREASE OR DECREASE WITH PSROS, BULLETIN OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF SURGEONS 59: 7 (1974).
WILLETT, D.E., PSRO TODAY - LAWYERS ASSESSMENT, NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE 292: 340 (1975).
WILLIAMSON, J.W., CONTINUING EDUCATION AND PATIENT CARE RESEARCH - PHYSICIAN RESPONSE TO SCREENING TEST RESULTS, JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION 201: 938 (1967).
WILLIAMSON, J.W., EVALUATING QUALITY OF PATIENT CARE - STRATEGY RELATING OUTCOME AND PROCESS ASSESSMENT, JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION 218: 564 (1971).

Information & Authors

Information

Published In

Science
Volume 200 | Issue 4344
26 May 1978

Submission history

Published in print: 26 May 1978

Permissions

Request permissions for this article.

Authors

Affiliations

Avedis Donabedian
School of Public Health, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor 48109.

Metrics & Citations

Metrics

Article Usage
Altmetrics

Citations

Export citation

Select the format you want to export the citation of this publication.

View Options

Get Access

Log in to view the full text

AAAS ID LOGIN

AAAS login provides access to Science for AAAS Members, and access to other journals in the Science family to users who have purchased individual subscriptions.

Log in via OpenAthens.
Log in via Shibboleth.
More options

Purchase digital access to this article

Download and print this article for your personal scholarly, research, and educational use.

Purchase this issue in print

Buy a single issue of Science for just $15 USD.

View options

PDF format

Download this article as a PDF file

Download PDF

Media

Figures

Multimedia

Tables

Share

Share

Share article link

Share on social media