The Lunar Laser Ranging Experiment: Accurate ranges have given a large improvement in the lunar orbit and new selenophysical information.
Abstract
The lunar ranging measurements now being made at the McDonald Observatory have an accuracy of 1 nsec in round-trip travel time. This corresponds to 15 cm in the one-way distance. The use of lasers with pulse-lengths of less than 1 nsec is expected to give an accuracy of 2 to 3 cm in the next few years. A new station is under construction in Hawaii, and additional stations in other countries are either in operation or under development. It is hoped that these stations will form the basis for a worldwide network to determine polar motion and earth rotation on a regular basis, and will assist in providing information about movement of the tectonic plates making up the earth's surface. Several mobile lunar ranging stations with telescopes having diameters of 1.0 m or less could, in the future, greatly extend the information obtainable about motions within and between the tectonic plates.
The data obtained so far by the McDonald Observatory have been used to generate a new lunar ephemeris based on direct numerical integration of the equations of motion for the moon and planets. With this ephemeris, the range to the three Apollo retroreflectors can be fit to an accuracy of 5 m by adjusting the differences in moments of inertia of the moon about its principal axes, the selenocentric coordinates of the reflectors, and the McDonald longitude. The accuracy of fitting the results is limited currently by errors of the order of an arc second in the angular orientation of the moon, as derived from the best available theory of how the moon rotates in response to the torques acting on it. Both a new calculation of the moon's orientation as a function of time based on direct numerical integration of the torque equations and a new analytic theory of the moon's orientation are expected to be available soon, and to improve considerably the accuracy of fitting the data.
The accuracy already achieved routinely in lunar laser ranging represents a hundredfold improvement over any previously available knowledge of the distance to points on the lunar surface. Already, extremely complex structure has been observed in the lunar rotation and significant improvement has been achieved in our knowledge of lunar orbit. The selenocentric coordinates of the retroreflectors give improved reference points for use in lunar mapping, and new information on the lunar mass distribution has been obtained. Beyond the applications discussed in this article, however, the history of science shows many cases of previously unknown phenomena discovered as a consequence of major improvements in the accuracy of measurements. It will be interesting to see whether this once again proves the case as we acquire an extended series of lunar distance observations with decimetric and then centimetric accuracy.
References
Laser Target on moon works for Air Force scientists, Bulletin Geodesique 94: 443 (1969).
ABALAKIN, V.K., ANALYSIS OF FIRST LASER ECHOES ON LUNA-21 REFLECTOR, COMPTES RENDUS HEBDOMADAIRES DES SEANCES DE L ACADEMIE DES SCIENCES SERIE B 276: 673 (1973).
Abbot, R. I., Astronomical Journal 78: 784 (1973).
Alley, C. O., The Application of Modern Physics to The Earth and Planetary Interiors (1969).
ALLEY, C.O., INTERNATIONAL ASTRONOMICAL UNION SYMPOSIUM 32: 86 (1968).
ALLEY, C.O., OPTICAL RADAR USING A CORNER REFLECTOR ON MOON, JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH 70: 2267 (1965).
ALLEY, C.O., APOLLO-11 LASER RANGING RETRO-REFLECTOR . INITIAL MEASUREMENTS FROM MCDONALD OBSERVATORY, SCIENCE 167: 368 (1970).
ALLEY, C.O., LASER RANGING RETRO-REFLECTOR . CONTINUING MEASUREMENTS AND EXPECTED RESULTS, SCIENCE 167: 458 (1970).
ALLEY, C.O., Apollo 11 Preliminary Science Report, NASA REPORT SP-214: 163 (1969).
Bender, P. L., in preparation.
BENDER, P.L., JET PROPULSION LABORATORY TECHNICAL MEMORANDUM 33-499: 178 (1971).
BENDER, P, ONE-WAY RADAR RANGE TO MOON, SCIENCE 168: 1012 (1970).
CALAME, O, GEODETIC MEASUREMENTS WITH LUNAR LASER-RANGING, ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS 4: 18 (1970).
CALAME, O, DETERMINATION OF LUNAR LIBRATION BY LASER MOON-RANGING, ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS 22: 75 (1973).
CALAME, O, FIRST LUMINOUS ECHOS ON MOON OBTAINED BY LASER TELEMETRY FROM PIC DU MIDI OBSERVATORY, COMPTES RENDUS HEBDOMADAIRES DES SEANCES DE L ACADEMIE DES SCIENCES SERIE B 270: 1637 (1970).
Carter, W. E., The AFCRL Lunar Laser Ranging Experiment In Arizona (1973).
CARTER, W.E., LIGHTWEIGHT CENTER-MOUNTED 152-CM F/2.5 CER-VIT MIRROR, APPLIED OPTICS 11: 467 (1972).
CARTER, W.E., OPERATIONAL TESTS OF AFCRL 152-CM TELESCOPE, APPLIED OPTICS 11: 1651 (1972).
CARTER, W.E., SPACE RESEARCH 12: 177 (1972).
CHANG, R.F., FAR-FIELD DIFFRACTION PATTERN FOR CORNER REFLECTORS WITH COMPLEX REFLECTION COEFFICIENTS, JOURNAL OF THE OPTICAL SOCIETY OF AMERICA 61: 431 (1971).
CHANG, R.F., SPACE RESEARCH 12: 247 (1972).
CHINNERY, M.A., IAU S 48: 215 (1972).
CHOLLET, F.L., MOVEMENTS OF INSTANTANEOUS AXIS OF ROTATION OF EARTH DEDUCED FROM EARTH-MOON LASER RANGING, ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS 9: 110 (1970).
COOK, A.H., PERSONAL COMMUNICATION.
DAHLEN, F.A., CORRECTION TO EXCITATION OF CHANDLER WOBBLE BY EARTHQUAKES, GEOPHYSICAL JOURNAL OF THE ROYAL ASTRONOMICAL SOCIETY 32: 203 (1973).
DICKE, R.H., SPACE RESEARCH 2: 287 (1961).
Eckert, W. J., Improved Lunar Ephemeris 1952-1959 (1954).
ECKHARDT, D.H., COMPUTER SOLUTIONS OF FORCED PHYSICAL LIBRATIONS OF MOON, ASTRONOMICAL JOURNAL 70: 466 (1965).
ECKHARDT, D.H., MOON 1: 264 (1970).
ECKHARDT, D.H., MOON 6: 127 (1973).
FALLER, J, LASER BEAM DIRECTED AT LUNAR RETRO-REFLECTOR ARRAY - OBSERVATIONS OF FIRST RETURNS, SCIENCE 166: 99 (1969).
FALLER, J. E., Geodesy Results Obtainable with Lunar Retroreflectors, GEOPHYSICAL MONOGRAPH SERIES 15: 261 (1972).
FALLER, J.E., LUNAR LASER REFLECTOR, SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN 222: 38 (1970).
FALLER, J.E., SPACE RESEARCH 12: 235 (1972).
FALLER, J.E., Apollo 14 Preliminary Science Report, NASA REPORT SP-272: 215 (1971).
FALLER, J.E., Apollo 15 Preliminary Science Report, NASA REPORT SP-389: 14 (1972).
FALLER, J.E., UNPUBLISHED ARTICLE.
FANSELOW, J.L., TRANSACTIONS OF THE AMERICAN GEOPHYSICAL UNION 53: 968 (1972).
FOURNET, M, SPACE RESEARCH 12: 261 (1972).
GAPOSCHKIN, E.M., EARTHS GRAVITY FIELD TO SIXTEENTH DEGREE AND STATION COORDINATES FROM SATELLITE AND TERRESTRIAL DATA, JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH 76: 4855 (1971).
GARTHWAITHE, K, ASTROPHYSICAL J 75: 1133 (1970).
GRASYUK, A.Z., SOVIET PHYSICS-DOKLADY 9: 162 (1964).
GUINOT, B, CHANDLERIAN WOBBLE FROM 1900 TO 1970, ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS 19: 207 (1972).
GUINOT, B, PERSONAL COMMUNICATION.
HAMMOND, A.L., LASER RANGING - MEASURING MOONS DISTANCE, SCIENCE 170: 1289 (1970).
Haubrich, R. A., Earthquake Displacement Fields and the Rotation of the Earth: 149 (1970).
HOFFMANN, W.F., IRE T MIL ELECTRON 4: 28 (1960).
ISRAEL, M, RESIDUAL DEFORMATION OF REAL EARTH MODELS WITH APPLICATION TO CHANDLER WOBBLE, GEOPHYSICAL JOURNAL OF THE ROYAL ASTRONOMICAL SOCIETY 32: 219 (1973).
Julian, R. S., Measure of the Moon (1967).
Kaula, W. M., The Moon 8: 287 (1973).
KAULA, W.M., POTENTIALITIES OF LUNAR LASER RANGING FOR MEASURING TECTONIC MOTIONS, PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY OF LONDON SERIES A-MATHEMATICAL PHYSICAL AND ENGINEERING SCIENCES 274: 185 (1973).
KOKURIN, Y. L., JETP LETTERS-USSR 3: 139 (1966).
KOKURIN, Y.L., KOSMICHESK ISSLED 4: 414 (1966).
KOKURIN, Y.L., KOSMICHESK ISSLED 5: 219 (1967).
KOKURIN, Y.L., KOSMICHESK ISSLED 6: 247 (1968).
KOKURIN, Y.L., PERSONAL COMMUNICATION.
KOKURIN, Y.L., SOV J QUANTUM ELECTR 1: 555 (1972).
KOZAI, Y, PERSONAL COMMUNICATION.
KOZAI, Y, SPACE RESEARCH 12: 211 (1972).
KOZIEL, K, CONSTANTS OF MOONS PHYSICAL LIBRATION DERIVED ON BASIS OF 4 SERIES OF HELIOMETRIC OBSERVATIONS FROM YEARS 1877 TO 1915, ICARUS 7: 1 (1967).
LEHR, C.G., TRANSPORTABLE LUNAR-RANGING SYSTEM, APPLIED OPTICS 11: 300 (1972).
LEHR, C.G., LUNAR RANGE MEASUREMENTS WITH A HIGH-RADIANCE FREQUENCY-DOUBLED NEODYMIUM-GLASS LASER SYSTEM, APPLIED OPTICS 12: 946 (1973).
LEHR, C.G., LASER TRANSIT-TIME MEASUREMENTS BETWEEN EARTH AND MOON WITH A TRANSPORTABLE SYSTEM, SCIENCE 180: 954 (1973).
LEHR, C.G., SPACE RESEARCH 12: 261 (1972).
MANSINHA, L, EFFECT OF EARTHQUAKES ON CHANDLER WOBBLE AND SECULAR POLAR SHIFT, JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH 72: 4731 (1967).
MEADE, B.K., PERSONAL COMMUNICATION.
Mulholland, J. D., Space Research 2: 1009 (1973).
MULHOLLAND, J.D., MOON 4: 155 (1972).
MULHOLLAND, J.D., SPACE RESEARCH 11: 97 (1971).
NORDTVEDT, K, TESTING RELATIVITY WITH LASER RANGING TO MOON, PHYSICAL REVIEW 170: 1186 (1968).
OESTERWINTER, C, CELESTIAL MECH 5: 317 (1972).
OHANDLEY, D.A., JPL321469 JET PROP L (1969).
Orsazg, A., Space Research 2: 1001 (1973).
ORSZAG, A, PERSONAL COMMUNICATION.
ORSZAG, A, PROGR RADIO SCI 3: 467 (1971).
ORSZAG, A, RADIO SCI 69: 1681 (1965).
ORSZAG, A, SPACE RESEARCH 12: 205 (1972).
ORSZAG, A, THESIS U PARIS SUD (1972).
Plotkin, H. H., Quantum Electronics III 2 (1964).
POULTNEY, S. K., IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON NUCLEAR SCIENCE 19 3: 12 (1972).
RAMASASTRY, J, TRANSACTIONS OF THE AMERICAN GEOPHYSICAL UNION 54: 228 (1973).
Rochester, M. G., Earthquake Displacement Fields and the Rotation of the Earth: 3 (1970).
ROSCH, J, B ASTRON 3: 453 (1968).
ROSCH, J, MOON 3: 448 (1972).
Shapiro, I. I., Earthquake Displacement Fields and the Rotation of the Earth: 284 (1970).
SILVERBERG, E.C., BULLETIN OF THE AMERICAN ASTRONOMICAL SOCIETY 4: 219 (1972).
Silverberg, R. C., in preparation.
SILVERBERG, E.C., SPACE RESEARCH 12: 219 (1972).
SMITH, D.E., POLAR MOTION FROM LASER TRACKING OF ARTIFICIAL SATELLITES, SCIENCE 178: 405 (1972).
SMULLIN, L.D., I ELEC ELECTRON ENG 50: 1703 (1962).
SMYLIE, D.E., J GEOPHYS RES 73: 7661 (1968).
TACHIBANA, A, SPACE RESEARCH 12: 187 (1972).
WILL, C.M., RELATIVISTIC GRAVITY IN SOLAR SYSTEM .1. EFFECT OF AN ANISOTROPIC GRAVITATIONAL MASS ON EARTH-MOON DISTANCE, ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL 165: 409 (1971).
Williams, J. G., The Moon 8: 469 (1973).
WILLIAMS, J.G., TRANSACTIONS OF THE AMERICAN GEOPHYSICAL UNION 53: 968 (1972).
Mulholland, J. D., The Moon, in press.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Already a Subscriber?Sign In
Information & Authors
Information
Published In

Science
Volume 182 | Issue 4109
19 October 1973
19 October 1973
Copyright
1973 by the American Association for the Advancement of Science.
Submission history
Published in print: 19 October 1973
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Article Usage
Altmetrics
Citations
Export citation
Select the format you want to export the citation of this publication.
Cited by
- Lunar Laser Ranging: A Continuing Legacy of the Apollo Program, Science, 265, 5171, (482-490), (1994)./doi/10.1126/science.265.5171.482
- Application of Space Technology to Geodynamics, Science, 213, 4503, (89-96), (1981)./doi/10.1126/science.213.4503.89
- Earth Rotation Measured by Lunar Laser Ranging, Science, 193, 4257, (997-999), (1976)./doi/10.1126/science.193.4257.997
Loading...
View Options
Get Access
Log in to view the full text
AAAS login provides access to Science for AAAS Members, and access to other journals in the Science family to users who have purchased individual subscriptions.
- Become a AAAS Member
- Activate your AAAS ID
- Purchase Access to Other Journals in the Science Family
- Account Help
Log in via OpenAthens.
Log in via Shibboleth.
More options
Purchase digital access to this article
Download and print this article for your personal scholarly, research, and educational use.
Buy a single issue of Science for just $15 USD.
View options
PDF format
Download this article as a PDF file
Download PDF





